Wednesday, January 7, 2009

30.3 Do you reccomend the 1 child policy?

Explain in a complete paragraph (5 sentences) what evidence you are using to support your strength of recommending the 1 child policy to fast growing countries.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

To tell the truth I really don't know what I should choose I think it's an very good idea to get their population down but I also think it's wrong that parents can't have an say on if they want more than one child. Personally I wouldn't want to follow these rules if I was in China, but I can't decide on what I think is right cause I agree on both.

Unknown said...

I do not like the 1 child policy because if a couple accidentally has more than 1 child i believe the child shouldnt die or get killed. It is not his or her fault that they were another child. But i understand that China needs less people. A less population is needed for China.

Anonymous said...

I recommended not recommend because people shouldn't be told how many they should have.

Anonymous said...

I recommended it not recommended because of key point and because people shouldn't be told how man kids they should have

Anonymous said...

i choose the one that says not recommended because of key point because i think that people shouldn't be telling other people how many kids should they have.

Anonymous said...

I Don't Like the 1 child policy because if i had child i would give him another sibling so he or she wouldn't fell lonely or play less.But china needs less people in its population because there is so much people in china, but still they shouldn't murder a persons child the person give birth to that baby for a reason so i think and should protest that 1 child policy shouldn't be a rule.

Anonymous said...

I voted for definitely not because I don't think people should be told how many babes to have.People shouldn't be told how many kids to have because if they want a girl and a boy to help around their house they should but they couldn't.People should be able to do what ever they want and have as many babes as they want.

Anonymous said...

I recommend with reservation because in the text it say that with the one child policy people who go by the policy the get rewards.The that don't go by the policy they will punishments.There was starvation because there is to many child so i do but some for it is wrong.

Anonymous said...

I recomend the 1 child policy because
it benefits you and doesn't benefits at the same time.It benefits you because it reduced strain in food and water supplies.It doesn't benefits you because people don't want to be told how many child they want.That want i can say.

Maureen Marie said...

Your answers are all interesting. I think the key here is to ANSWER THIS QUESTION AS DEMOGRAPHERS.

We know that a demographer is someone who studies population -- and looks at the changes, the deaths, the births, etc.

As a demographer, I would recommend the policy because 5 million people dying of starvation per year is NOT OK. That seems like a severe problem that needs a solution.

As a person, and an American that believes in my freedoms, I would not recommend it because it takes people's freedom of choice away.
Boy, I have to agree with Yonetta on this one - it is a tough one.

Neither option is ideal, but I believe that one is better than the other -- the population needs to be controlled for a bit.

Anonymous said...

I think it is a very responsible thing to say so the one child policy is the right thing to do so thats why I said yes.

Anonymous said...

I do like the 1 the 1 child policy because some people when they had a baby gile they was not happey so they will kill the baby gile in tell they have a baby boy

Anonymous said...

i think that 1 child policy is a good idea because they are going to get more people so more population.

Anonymous said...

the one child policy is a good idea because the babies do not have to stave to death and what i would change is why people d not want girls and why boy were more wanted.